Home > Moodle > Moodle 2.0 wherefore art thou?

Moodle 2.0 wherefore art thou?

Moodle 2.0…the Godsend to LMS users worldwide…under development for over 2 years now…

Someone emailed me today asking: O 2.0, O 2.0 wherefore art thou 2.0?

He/she may have even posted here: http://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=145632

Actually, that is a very good question, but one that doesn’t really concern me. The person who emailed me (why he/she emailed me is a mystery) stated that Martin (you know, king of the disciples), stated at the recent UK moot that he has decreed Moodle 2.0 Stable will be out in July so all in the Northern Hemisphere will be able to upgrade before school starts in the fall.

Really?

I mean, REALLY?

1. It’s May and there is not even a beta,

2. Have you downloaded what is there now? I have and it’s not pretty, and

3. Anyone who upgrades their campus site to 2.0 this summer (alleged stable or not) should be fired for gross incompetence.

Given Moodle’s abysmal track record with security, privacy, and FERPA compliance the real question people should be asking is O 2.0, O 2.0, how secure art thou Moodle 2.0? The answer to that question remains to be seen…but then again, I may know someone willing to help answer that one ;-)

Related posts:

  1. “Upgrade to Moodle 2.0 then restoring back to 1.99″ — It’s your hosts problem? Tweet Just when I think I’ve seen it all, something...
  2. New Moodle Leadership: Larry, Mo, and Curly leading moodle into the future ;-) Tweet It’s official…Larry, Mo, and Curly leading Moodle into the...
  3. It’s Official…Upgrading to Moodle 2.0 “Not Recommended”? Tweet Yet another cry for help in the moodle.org forums...
  4. Mo’s Logic — Always good for a laugh :-) Tweet A couple days ago, I reported about the hair-brained...
  5. Moodle “End of Life” policy Tweet Now there’s a question all Moodle users should be...

  1. netbuoy
    May 4th, 2010 at 12:10 | #1

    It would seem that the current release schedule in the “roadmap” may have first appeared in mid-December http://docs.moodle.org/en/index.php?title=Roadmap&oldid=66407 with the pushing of the release date from February to July. While there have been a number of people fiddling with dates (the first beta was to be released in April) it is clear that Dougiamas is trying to stick with the fiction that a July release date is a boon to North American system administrators.

    However, with April having come and gone, we have now been offered a “beta preview (see http://www.moodlemonthly.com/2010/martin-dougiamas-outlines-moodle2-at-mootuk10/) which apparently was not “newsy” enough to merit mention on Moodle.org (http://moodle.org/news/.) Stumped as to what that means? You are not alone. Seems to me that it means that there won’t be any beta release any time soon….

    With Moodle HQ waxing so insistent, one has to wonder as to the nature of the private correspondence between Tim Hunt (Moodle Dev) and Dougiamas (Moodle Dad) look like, in as much as Tim says (at http://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=144626&parent=633470):

    “When dates are mentioned in relation to Moodle releases,
    they should never be taken to mean anything like a schedule.
    At best, they are aspirations. They also, sometimes, serve
    to focus the developers’ minds a bit.

    I think the current aspiration is based on the fact
    that if people in the Northern Hemisphere are going to update
    during the long summer break, then the release needs to be in
    July, and extrapolating back form that, you get to a beta in
    March, which, when that date was picked about a month ago,
    was not completely implausible.

    I think sam’s assessment is a bit more realistic. Beta in
    April or May, then see how testing goes, and we shall see.”

    Software development, especially with respect to complex systems, will often go through multiple betas, then multiple release candidates, before a production release, and the release of a hugely buggy product even after such a process has dogged vendors such as Microsoft. Yet, having yet to release its first beta, Moodle HQ seems still insistent on fanning the flames of a july release. One can just imagine the “intensive testing” and release cycle for beta(s) and rcs in the next 8 weeks….

    Frankly, no sane system administrator is going to put Moodle 2 into production this year (certainly not after the last gradebook fiasco). If Moodle is as successful as Dougiamas claims, why not take one’s time and make sure that Moodle 2 is picture perfect, as opposed to having your base hurl epithets at you for making their lives miserable?

  2. May 4th, 2010 at 13:32 | #2

    @netbuoy

    Frankly, no sane system administrator is going to put Moodle 2 into production this year (certainly not after the last gradebook fiasco).

    You’re right about that…only the ones who buy into the Moodle hype will make their users the “beta testers” for Moodle this fall.

  1. No trackbacks yet.